The recent Ubuntu Free Culture Showcase competition produced some good work. Lots of great photos and plenty of interesting music tracks were submitted.
But only four videos…
This made me think. Why only four? Was it because we didn’t talk about it enough? Or maybe there’s just not that many Ubuntu users interested in video and animation? Or… maybe it’s simply too hard to create a nice video piece on Ubuntu?
To answer this, I set myself a challenge:
Create a short animation to promote the competition, using only free software on Ubuntu.
To be more specific: only a GUI software, no scripting or programming allowed.
Artistically, I’ve set myself some interesting constraints, too:
- only two colours can be used: Ubuntu orange and white,
- all visuals must be built using only one element – a circle.
You can’t get more Ubuntu than that, I thought.
Being familiar with many proprietary animation packages, from Flash to AfterEffects and 3dsmax, and having some experience with GIMP and Inkscape on Ubuntu, I estimated five days of work for a 50-second animation with music.
And here’s the result:
Ubuntu Free Culture Showcase – animated intro from Mat Tomaszewski on Vimeo.
Also, check a hi-res OGV.
The Making Of
After some initial sketching using the ancient tools of Pen and Paper, I knew what I wanted to achieve. The animation would consist of three parts, introducing Music, Video and Photo part of the competition. The background music would be (of course) the winning track from the 10.10 edition.
Since the whole animation was to be made of dots (circles), the package had to support timeline-based animation of multiple objects, I thought. That rules out tools like Processing, as they require coding.
Something like, say, Flash or AfterEffects, just Free and Open Source and running on Ubuntu.
This was the first hurdle. Neither PiTiVi, nor kdenlive or any other package I tried could do that.
Fortunately, there was Blender.
Blender’s great. Not perfect, but getting there really fast. It’s very powerful and the UI is logical and consistent, even if initially some things (like right-click to select) may seem counterintuitive. One introductory video tutorial (loads of them on YouTube) was enough to get me through the initial learning curve.
To create the effects you see in the video, I mostly used the array modifier, which can be animated using controller objects, like a path (which lenght controls the count) or an Empty (to create rotation or scale effects). Again, many great examples and video tutorials are available online.
Once the three parts of the animation were ready (each one in a separate Scene) I used the Sequence Editor to put them together.
I then used Audacity to trim and fade the soundtrack (no problems there), Inkscape to create the credits and finally rendered to MP4, using the Blender’s native renderer. To convert to OGV, I used kdenlive, which again was very smooth.
Problems? There were a few. By far the biggest of them was lack of sound in Blender. I ended up googling for solutions, but the command-line magic I applied didn’t help. I’m still not sure what was wrong, and it slowed me down quite a bit, as I had to preview using the rendered movies, rather than instant preview within the app. If there was anything that would stop me from using Blender professionally, it would be that.
Otherwise, I had some really great time. :)
Oh, and if you want to start blending right away, here’s the source file for the animation. Enjoy designing on Ubuntu!
amazing!
Thats really neat, mat_t!
People often complain that the design team dint use free software! Nice way to silence the critics and showcase free software! ;-)
“lack of sound in Blender”? Check this: http://itmages.ru/image/view/67644/510d378c
@dmitry Thanks for your reply, I know how to add sound to the timeline, the problem was I didn’t hear any sound when previewing.
Really excellent work.
Hmm… I can hear the sound (at least in current 2.5 beta) while previewing using Ctrl+A. Working on Ubuntu 10.10 Ad currently ;)
I used 2.49.
Looking forward to see your ad! :)
Wow! damn cool :) Great work Mat
@Goran @Ahmed thanks!
“Or… maybe it’s simply too hard to create a nice video piece on Ubuntu?”
Yes.
The tools simply aren’t there. The best video editor I could find lacks simple features like snapping clips to the ruler or each other. There is no video compositing tool (that is actually usable or up-to-date). It’s frustrating.
See previous one, btw: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1HI7zmlvzIM
And, your video is really cool, as others said ;)
Kdenlive is my best friend. Not perfect but very usable and evolving app!
Brilliant very professional :)
cool! I’d been meaning to check out the state of animation tools in linux for a while, I guess this weekend I’ll mess with blender :)
The real elephant in the room is “Where is the pro video editing application?”
Hi! Great example! But I think that this area could be improved a lot, it’s necessary a powerful and simple video editor (as iLife?)
We’re on the right way! ;)
Best regards!
That would make a nice full-screen introduction video after installing natty :)
Hi,Matt.I upload a video at Ubuntu Free Culture Showcase, but something i don’t made well, because my video is in my channel but no at Ubuntu Free Culture Showcase, jaja..
http://vimeo.com/16091962
Sorry for my english ;-)
For the sound problems I’ve found a solution, by samuraidanieru, on Blenderartist. You must add this line at the end of your /home/user/.profile file:
export SDL_AUDIODRIVER=pulse
It works for me :D
Turned out as generic Ubuntu AD: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hgiy2YBO7Ic